Cracker Barrel scored high on texture too: not too pliable, not too crumbly. Is there a perfect cheddar? Who’s to say? But ...

This is the product's overall performance score, based on key tests conducted by our industry experts in the CHOICE labs.

Food Republic ranked boxed mac and cheese from best to worst, and our top choice for this satisfying treat is Cracker Barrel Sharp Cheddar Macaroni and Cheese. There are a few things that count ...