The show experienced a resurgence in the early 2000s when the network created Nickelodeon Games and Sports for Kids, called Nick GAS, and began replaying episodes of Legends of the Hidden Temple.

Nick Borey lived every millennial's dream as a contestant on the first-ever season of Legends of the Hidden Temple. Borey, now 44, tells PEOPLE he grew up near Nickelodeon Studios in Orlando, Fla.