That Goodfellas review is featured high up in the “Best of” section of Portnoy’s popular One Bite Pizza Reviews YouTube channel and has garnered 2.3 million views.

Four years ago Dave Portnoy gave Goodfellas one of his worst reviews ever but locals rallied around the restaurant. See where he went on this visit.

The joint received so much praise from Barstool Sports founder and pizza review king Dave Portnoy that it ran out of ingredients.

The joint received so much praise from Barstool Sports founder and pizza review king Dave Portnoy that it ran out of ingredients. Portnoy’s pizza reviews are famously known for being ranked on a ...