The punny headlines practically write themselves, as Charmin fans who were flushed with pride at having won free toilet paper for a year suddenly found their wins had been wiped away, and their ...

We are not just talking about a few rolls of paper. The contest was to win an 18-pack of “Charmin Super Mega” paper, which averages $30. That’s $30 times 12 months or $360 worth for the year.